Showing posts with label Fannie Flagg. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fannie Flagg. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 9, 2024

Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe by Fannie Flagg

 Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe by Fannie Flagg - 416 pages, ⭐☆☆☆☆

Evelyn Couch is a middle-aged woman unhappy in her marriage, who meets an elderly woman named Ninny Threadgoode at a nursing home.  Mrs. Threadgoode tells her stories about the small town of Whistle Stop, Alabama, and all the people who used to live there, including the couple who owned the Whistle Stop Cafe.

This is one of the few books whose movie adaptations are far better than the original work.  The book tries to do too much at once.  It tries to be character-driven, but has too many characters, all of whom are too underdeveloped to carry the plot.  It tries to tell a non-chronological story in two separate timelines, from two different characters' perspectives, while also interspersing newspaper articles written by a third character throughout, without a clear reason for the unusual structure, juxtaposition of past and present, or the multiple points of view.  It tries to be a love story, a history of Whistle Stop, a crime drama, an intergenerational friendship story, and a woman's journey to find herself.  It tries to address racism while viewing the Old South with a nostalgic lens, without understanding the contradictions inherent in that.  Simply put, this is an incredibly ambitious book, but whether due to lack of skill, lack of experience, or lack of revision, Fannie Flagg could not pull so many elements together into a cohesive whole.  

Fortunately, many of the book's issues were fixed in the movie adaptation, which Fannie Flagg was involved in writing.  The number of characters got trimmed down for the movie, the remaining characters are more developed, and the plot follows a more chronological progression.  I would consider the book to be the first draft, and the movie the final draft.  

Although I enjoyed Idgie and Ruth's love story in the novel (it's toned down substantially in the movie), I found the rest of the book boring and infuriating rather than folksy and charming.  I quickly grew tired of hearing about Dot Weems's "other half" in the newspaper clippings, and wished Evelyn would just walk away from Mrs. Threadgoode so Evelyn could eat her candy bars in peace, and I no longer had to be the captive audience for another of Mrs. Threadgoode's stories.  More so than anger or boredom, however, I felt immeasurable disappointment.  There is a good concept here, as evidenced by the excellent movie adaptation, but it's weighed down by trying to do and be too much at once.  It reads more like an experiment in new techniques than a finished novel.  

I am happy that Fannie Flagg was able to overcome the fear and embarrassment she felt about writing due to her dyslexia, but this book is, quite frankly, a mess.  Shannon Hale once said, "I’m writing a first draft and reminding myself that I’m simply shoveling sand into a box, so that later, I can build castles."  Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe is not a castle -- it's sand in a box.  It reads like an early draft, but is presented as a finished work, which leaves me no choice but to rate it based on the same standards I would rate other finished works.  Therefore, I rate it one star out of five.  

Saturday, December 23, 2023

Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe by Fannie Flagg

Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe by Fannie Flagg-395 pages

⭐✩✫✫✫

This is our next book for the Book to Movie Club chosen by our group. I have to be honest. I didn't like it very much. I finished it, of course, but it has borderline racist overtones. The African-American characters are very "stereotypical." Also, the timeline throughout the book is scattered and off. The stories are all over the place and it doesn't seem for most of the book to be a cohesive, coherent story. It reads mostly like a lonely old woman babbling to a younger woman at a nursing home about the "good old days." Mrs. Threadgoode (the old woman) and Evelyn Couch do strike up a friendship, but I just didn't get emotionally invested in the characters. Lastly, it seems like a creative writing class project and not a published novel. It seems the author was going for a folksy feel, but it didn't work for me. Overall, I would not recommend this book. However, maybe this will be a rare occasion when the movie is better than the book (it definitely was!). 


Saturday, September 4, 2021

The Wonder Boy of Whistle Stop: A Novel by Fannie Flagg

 


              The Wonder Boy of Whistle Stop: A Novel by Fannie Flagg-282 pages

The story follows a little boy throughout his life.  Raised in a small town, enduring an accident that could have left him bitter.  Instead, the book focuses on the people that made a difference in his life and how he chose to rise above his disability. Heartwarming and inspirational.  Told with Fannie Flagg's humor.

I loved this book.  It was so cool to see how everyone stayed in touch over the years.  And Fannie Flagg makes me laugh out loud.

Tuesday, November 17, 2020

The Wonder Boy of Whistle Stop by Fannie Flagg

 304 pages

"Bud Threadgoode grew up in the bustling little railroad town of Whistle Stop with his mother, Ruth, church-going and proper, and his Aunt Idgie, the fun-loving hell-raiser. Together they ran the town’s popular Whistle Stop Cafe, known far and wide for its fun and famous fried green tomatoes. And as Bud often said of his childhood to his daughter Ruthie, 'How lucky can you get?'

"But sadly, as the railroad yards shut down and Whistle Stop became a ghost town, nothing was left but boarded-up buildings and memories of a happier time.

"Then one day, Bud decides to take one last trip, just to see what has become of his beloved Whistle Stop. In so doing, he discovers new friends, as well as surprises about Idgie’s life, about Ninny Threadgoode and other beloved Fannie Flagg characters, and about the town itself. He also sets off a series of events, both touching and inspiring, which change his life and the lives of his daughter and many others. Could these events all be just coincidences? Or something else? And can you really go home again?"  --from the publisher

I liked it, but didn't love it. And I'm not sure why. It has all the elements of a great book, but I feel like it just missed the mark. So much of the book is retelling incidents from the original "Fried Green Tomatoes" that I got kind of bored waiting for something new. I give it three out of five stars, but I'm in the minority according to the high Amazon and Goodreads ratings.

Monday, December 19, 2016

The Whole Town's Talking by Fannie Flagg








The Whole Town's Talking by Fannie Flagg by 432 pages
Elmwood Springs, Missouri, is a small town like any other, but something strange is happening at the cemetery. Still Meadows, as it’s called, is anything but still. Original, profound, The Whole Town’s Talking, a novel in the tradition of Thornton Wilder’s Our Town and Flagg’s own Can’t Wait to Get to Heaven, tells the story of Lordor Nordstrom, his Swedish mail-order bride, Katrina, and their neighbors and descendants as they live, love, die, and carry on in mysterious and surprising ways.

Lordor Nordstrom created, in his wisdom, not only a lively town and a prosperous legacy for himself but also a beautiful final resting place for his family, friends, and neighbors yet to come. “Resting place” turns out to be a bit of a misnomer, however. Odd things begin to happen, and it starts the whole town talking.

With her wild imagination, great storytelling, and deep understanding of folly and the human heart, the beloved Fannie Flagg tells an unforgettable story of life, afterlife, and the remarkable goings-on of ordinary people. In The Whole Town’s Talking, she reminds us that community is vital, life is a gift, and love never dies.

**I love (almost) everything F.F. has written! Getting to revisit Elmwood Springs for what seems to be the last time is bittersweet. We get to check in on old characters as well as meeting some new/old ones and the thought of this particular afterlife is pretty neat. 



Thursday, January 7, 2016

Daisy Fay and the Miracle Man by Fannie Flagg

book cover of 

Daisy Fay and the Miracle Man


    Daisy Fay and the Miracle Man by Fannie Flagg--336 pages




In Fannie Flagg’s high-spirited first novel, we meet Daisy Fay Harper in the spring of 1952, where she’s “not doing much except sitting around waiting for the sixth grade.” When she leaves Shell Beach, Mississippi, in September 1959, she is packed up and ready for the Miss America Pageant, vowing “I won’t come back until I’m somebody.” But in our hearts she already is.

Sassy and irreverent from the get-go, Daisy Fay takes us on a rollicking journey through her formative years on the Gulf Coast of Mississippi. There, at The End of the Road of the South, the family malt shop freezer holds unspeakable things, society maven Mrs. Dot hosts Junior Debutante meetings and shares inspired thoughts for the week (such as “sincerity is as valuable as radium”), and Daisy Fay’s Daddy hatches a quick-cash scheme that involves resurrecting his daughter from the dead in a carefully orchestrated miracle. Along the way, Daisy Fay does a lot of growing up, emerging as one of the most hilarious, appealing, and prized characters in modern fiction.


I have not read a Fannie Flagg I didn't like! This one is no exception. It is written like a diary, so it makes for a quick read! As with all Fannie Flagg novels, there is a great cast of characters.









Monday, April 14, 2014

All-Girl Filling Stations Last Reunion
BY:  Fannie Flagg

All-Girl Filling Stations Last Reunion  By: Fannie Flagg  347 pages
This is what I would describe as happy story, with two, easy to love characters.  Sookie and Fritzie are the center of this fun and thought provoking story with many secondary characters who add a little more humor and madness.  There is a lot of switching between past and present, but the timelines are both interesting.  Sookie is older (almost 60) when we meet her in the late 20th century and Fritzi is a young girl, who becomes what they refer to as a WASP, Women Air-force Service Pilot, during world war II.   
Sookie's past soon catches up with the present when she finds out more about who she really is and what part Fritzie played in her life.

This book is not what I thought it would be about, and though I enjoyed it, I think the title is a little deceptive.


Wednesday, January 22, 2014

The All-Girl Filling Station's Last Reunion By Fannie Flagg

The All-Girl Filling Station's Last Reunion:  A Novel by Fannie Flagg - 347 pages

Mrs. Sookie Poole has just married off her last daughter and is looking forward to relaxing, feeding her backyard birds and traveling with her husband.  But it is not to be as an unexpected package arrives one day and suddenly she finds herself questioning who she really is.  The story leads us back in time to the 1940's when the United States is getting pulled into WWII.  We meet a family in Iowa who has four girls who take over the running of their fathers filling station.  Soon, male drivers from all over the mid-west are coming to the station..not just to fill up but to see the girls!  Fannie Flagg once more delivers a wonderful story of love, forgiveness and the varying aspects of human nature.  We also learn that no matter what our age we can gain inspiration from the most unexpected places that will ultimately bring out the best in us.